A temporary home and repository for television and film critic Daniel Fienberg, formerly of HitFix.com and Zap2it.com and one half of The Firewall & Iceberg Podcast.
Friday, October 05, 2007
So about that "Friday Night Lights" premiere...
I spent nine months last year on this blog and Zap2it's myriad outlets trying to get everybody I know to watch "Friday Night Lights." I told my friends. I told my family. I told the occasional people who would interview me for the radio or whatever. I would occasionally shake random strangers in the street, grab them by the shoulders and yell, "You fool! Why aren't you watching 'Friday Night Lights'?"
So I'm not going to sit here at my keyboard and say, "I'm not sure that the 'Friday Night Lights' that's premiering tonight is really the 'Friday Night Lights' I wanted you to watch last season." I'm not going to tell you that you should skip tonight's season premiere, because what are you gonna do instead, watch "Moonlight"? Watch "K-Ville" repeats on FOX? Seriously?
Everybody else I know (I only know odd people) has already written their "Why I'm uncomfortable with the start of the 'Friday Night Lights' season" article, review or blog post, so here's another. I hate to be original.
Follow through after the bump. There are going to be huge spoilers for the premiere and rather vague spoilers about the next two episodes, which have also been sent to critics. You've been warned.
In the past week, the industry trade paper Variety has run both a review of "Friday Night Lights" and a roundtable critical discussion of the show's opening episodes. In the process, at least three alleged critics have said almost the exact same thing: The things that happen at the end of the season premiere are bad, but I can't say anything negative about them because the show's creative team has earned my faith and my unqualified acceptance that if they make mistakes, they'll fix them so fast that they weren't mistakes at all.
That's not the job of a critic, kids.
The producers of "24" start off every single season with six great episodes, dick around for 12 episodes and then close with six strong episodes, during which fans say, "Yeah, those middle episodes *all* sucked, but I had faith that the producers would right the ship." But. But. But. But those 12 episodes were horrible, they floundered and stumbled and bumbled and meandered and maybe they righted the ship and maybe they didn't, but the half a season in the middle was worse that "Threat Matrix." Fans have faith in show creators to fix things, they have confidence that they'll make things right. Critics look at what's there and that's what they address.
One fabulous season of TV hasn't earned the producers of "Friday Night Lights" a pass. Unfortunately, it's raised expectations. The first three episodes of "FNL" for this second season are *not* bad. It really hasn't become "One Tree Hill" while it was on vacation.
The things that work in the first few episodes still work gloriously. Eric and Tami Taylor remain my favorite couple on TV and an Emmy-giving universe in which television professionals fail to recognize that Kyle Chandler and Connie Britton are at the very peak of the profession doesn't deserve to be taken seriously. The new season finds Coach and Mrs. Coach separated just at the moment they need each other most, him with a new job in the big city and her (within minutes of the start of the premiere) with a new baby.
As their daughter Julie, Aimee Teegarden is sculpting the most believable portrait of teenage femininity since Claire Danes in "My So-Called Life" and the relationship between Julie and Zach Gilford's Matt Saracen has always rung true. The premiere finds Julie and Matt experiencing their own tension and distance, as Julie deals with the changes in her family and Matt faces another season of football.
While there were plenty of moments early last season when certain actors -- Minka Kelly, Taylor Kitsch, Scott Porter -- did show certain signs of just how green they were, every member of the cast has the chance to shine before the end.
If I'm being frank, the show's problems began with the finale of the first season. As I wrote extensively at the time, they made a finale that felt like they almost hoped the show didn't come back. They let the Panthers win, which was a mistake. They let wheelchair-bound QB Jason Street suddenly become a football strategic mastermind, which was a mistake. They pushed Landry (the marvelous Jessie Plemons) and Tyra (the always better-than-expected Adrianne Palicki) in the direction of a romance, which was a mistake. They did a bunch of things that were aimed at bringing the show to a happy, hopeful, satisfying series conclusion. And then NBC brought them back (and canned Kevin Reilly, the man who brought them back).
The second season begins roughly eight months later, which has allowed the show's producers to reboot several characters in ways that dismiss the journeys they went on last season. It was a long road for Gaius Charles' Smash to regain the support of viewers and become a smarter, more humble, heroic character, but in the eight months we were away, he's back to being the brash, ego-driven Smash from the pilot. It was a long road for Kitsch's Riggins to go from a drunk, womanizing burn-out to a mostly sober, responsible teammate, but in the eight months we were away, he's back to being that guy who shows up at practice drunk and takes pleasure in bedding twins, just because he can. Here again, the producers obviously realized that they'd made everything too stable by the first season finale, so they pushed the reset button. The transitions for Teegarden's Julie (more pouty than we remember), Kelly's Lyla (more Christian than we remember), for Brad Leland's Buddy Garrity (more drunk than we remember) are all much more plausible.
When talking about what goes wrong with the premiere and what hasn't been fixed or smoothed out in the two subsequent episodes, it's necessary to talk about Tyra and Landry. But first I wanna note that lots of things happened last season that even the biggest fans had trouble defending and they were usually the biggest plotpoints, the moments of high drama amidst the minutiae of small town life and football-as-religion. "That's such a 'Star Is Born' cliche!" people cried when Jason Street was injured in the pilot, forcing Matt Saracen into a featured role. "How are they ever going to redeem that character?" people wailed when Lyla screwed her paralyzed boyfriend's best friend. "Are they seriously doing *this* plotline," folks groused when Smash began taking steroids to improve his ranking in a touting publication. The team staging a walk-out due to a racist coach, a Katrina victim nearly getting the team put on probation, Riggins and the MILF next door... The season was full of moments that seemed iffy and many of 'em (most? nearly all?) were worked out satisfactorily, albeit faster and easier than might have happened in real life.
The things that went wrong last year were, if anything, a product of being too perfectly designed for a show of this nature. They were attempts to use the conventions of the sports genre to touch on the obligatory conflicts of the genre.
[OK. Last warning. Spoilers and some such!!! STOP READING!]
Landry knocking a guy upside the head with a pipe and killing him? That's just the producers coming up with big plot points to get buzz, because even crappy buzz isn't worse than no buzz. And I don't much care what Jason Katims has said to the contrary in interviews. I blame Ben Silverman. Just on principle.
Some reviewers have said that the premiere subplot in which Tyra is arbitrarily stalked by the man who assaulted her last season and in a tragic twist he ends up [last spoiler warning!!!!] dead and, presumably, dumped in the river is less like something from "FNL" and more like something from "One Tree Hill," though as dedicated "OTH" fans know even that silly, silly show didn't go so far as to have Peyton (or any of the other Ravens) kill her crazed fake brother. It's bad enough that the stalker plot returned in the premiere. Sure, we knew it was going to return eventually, but what was the guy doing for eight months? And why is he suddenly menacing her at all hours and in relatively public places? What does he think is going to happen? And it's bad enough that the scenes with the aspiring rapist are shot like they were taken from a slasher movie, rather than from the best directed show on TV. But did Landry need to kill the guy? Did they need to reshoot the scene, in fact, so that Landry kills the guy in cold blood, as he's turning away vanquished, rather than in total self-defense as in the original version of the premiere?
The mechanics here should be beneath the writers of such a good show. For most of last season, Tyra was the strong and capable girl, the girl you'd bet could take care of herself. She reduced Landry to a stuttering boob as a girl of that sort would do to a guy of that sort. But the producers realized that Plemmons is really good and that his scenes with Tyra, however awkward, were gold. So they said, "What can we do to make this work? What can we do to make her weak enough to need him and to make him manly enough to somehow be worthy of her?" How do lazy Hollywood minds accomplish such things? Naturally, they made Tyra into a victim, a sexual victim. Even that wasn't enough. So they made Landry try out for football, despite the fact that in a community like Dillon, a kid with no athletic interests doesn't magically say, "OK, today I try out for football" and even make the JV bench, given what we've seen of Dillon's Pop Warner devotion. That's stupid and I found it nearly unforgivable when I heard it was happening. That was before I knew we'd be introduced to Landry: Killing Machine. Basically the writers realized that the only way they could bring together these two characters loved by fans was to make them into two entirely different characters, incompatible with the characters they once were. To hell with it.
It's not a little mistake. For a show even an iota less wonderful than "Friday Night Lights," it would be "Jump the Shark"-level "Bad."
[Those are only spoilers for the premiere. Here come vaguely spoilers for other upcoming episodes.]
The so-called-reviewers at Variety said they had faith that "FNL" would work things out, but the Landry-Tyra subplots get worse in subsequent episodes. The characters get further and further from where they used to be and become more and more removed from the universe of the show. A change in Julie and Matt's relationship makes sense, but the new arrival in Matt's house is laugh-out-loud silly. You knew Coach Taylor wouldn't stay away from Dillon and the Panthers all season, but his path back into fold jeopardizes some of the things I most respect about the character. And Riggins and Street are heading someplace wacky at the end of the third episode and nothing good can happen there.
You know, this is long enough. I just wanted to chime in.
Now watch "Friday Night Lights." Its problems shouldn't excused and I don't have faith that they're going to be fixed to my satisfaction, but damned if I don't want to keep the show around.
Labels: Friday Night Lights, TV
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Great review/rant. I especially love how you call the writers on weakening Tyra by making her a victim of sexual assault. It bothered me a little bit last year, but now that I know the true goal of that storyline it actually offends me.ReplyDelete
I've only seen the premiere episode on Yahoo TV, but what troubled me the most was how they put up the version where Landry killed the guy with a bottle by accident, then quickly took it down and replaced it with Landry cold bloodedly killing the guy with a pipe. The first version was bad enough, but when I saw the second version I got worried. Really, really worried. It concerns me that the story doesn't get any better in the next few episodes.
The TV commercials show the bottle version, not the pipe version. I wonder why. And have you heard the radio ads? "Friday Night Lights returns tonight, and in the first episode alone, one couple begins, another ends, and there's a MURDER!" Yikes.
I'm going to keep watching, but MAN am I worried. Have I said "worried" and "concerned" enough in this post yet?
Daniel, I am most grateful for you writing out this rant: it kept me from going off into a far less eloquent on the same subject, instead being able to link here in full agreement.ReplyDelete
I think the most important distinction you make is between the racism/steroids/adultery storylines and this one: this is not the same, and lacks any connection to Dillon and football.
And there's the thing: I know it isn't a show about football, but it at least used to be a show about a football-crazed community. But the town of Dillon was all but removed: from the credits, from the series, and from the plot. Instead, we have murder.
I'll throw a hail mary out, and flash back to Veronica Mars' second season (I just finished rewatching the first on DVD): based on network pressure, and after an almost perfect first season, they introduced a bus crash and a possible homicide which lacked the personal connection to the show's original noir setting.
The relationships core to the series didn't change (Just as Tami/Eric were a highlight here), but the plot went in a direction that made the show a shell of its former shelf.
I think that my faith has certainly been tested, and I don't think this will be a simple bounce back like we saw in season one.
I hope it came across as "impassioned" in addition to "rant-y" because I want it to be clear that if I didn't love the damn show so much, I wouldn't have felt invested enough to be so worried/concerned/unhappy. I mean, heck, I'd still love for the show to become a hit, by hook or by crook. Then folks can go back and watch the first season on DVD.ReplyDelete
Carrie -- I hadn't heard that radio add. I like the TV add that goes something like "Finally on Friday, it's 'Friday Night Lights' having its Friday premiere this Friday night..." It makes me giggle each time.
Myles -- The comparison you made to "Veronica Mars" is a good one, albeit a worst case scenario. By the end of the second season of V.Mars, as much as I sometimes still loved it (I mean, they employed Guttenberg!!!), I often felt like it might have been better preserved as a one-season wonder. After the third season, I was actively (albeit tacitly) rooting for it not to get renewed because they were beginning to soil the memory of that great first season.
I'm taking a wait-and-see attitude, but since I've already seen three episodes, it'll be several weeks til I get a new one.
Knock on stuff. Wood stuff...
Excellent article. Love the 24 rant, pretty much the reason I have no plans to watch this season.ReplyDelete
I too hated the ending. Not sure I feel as betrayed as you in getting people to watch for the past year but the point is taken. My big problem is that there really is no clean way out of this for either character.
I haven't seen the next couple of episodes yet but I'm just kind of hoping that the rest of the show continues to deliver the characters and stories which made me love this show and that I can ignore the silliness of the murder plotline.
I think this is the best review I've read about the new season. I read sides/spoilers long before the premiere aired, and I seriously thought they might be fakes. Landry on the team? The murder? Carlotta (whose accent is horrid, by the way)?ReplyDelete
I was saddened by the Matt/Julie situation, but it did seem to make sense. And given her young age, I think Aimee Teegarden is the star of the younger cast. She absolutely inhabits this character.
Speaking of characters reverting to their old ways, why is Saracen so meek and underconfident again? This disappointed me too. Finally, I may be alone in this, but I really didn't want Riggins and Lyla resurrected, so to speak, in any way. Minka Kelly improved a lot last year, but I still don't find her strong enough to be occupying center stage again.
As for Tyra, you've said it all.
Tis is one of the best shows on Television.The production is nearly flawless. The characters are well written, but you can tell the actors are given a lot of freedom and they aren't just reading crappy dialogue straight from the script. The setting is so real, and the use of lighting in the scenes is really amazing.Enjoi all eps Friday Night Lights DownloadReplyDelete